EU top court adviser issues opinion on police use of phone location data

Follow 9News Nigeria On Social Media

Social sharing

An opinion issued by a senior adviser to the European Union’s top court could have far-reaching consequences for criminal investigations going forward after he said that data-retention practices used by Irish police in a high-profile murder case contravened EU law.

In 2015, Graham Dwyer was convicted of the murder of childcare worker Elaine O’Hara three years previously, with the data gathered by authorities from mobile phones being key to the guilty verdict.

The case came to the European Court of Justice following an appeal by Dwyer who argued that Ireland’s data retention law was contrary to the bloc’s legislation on the matter.

Manuel Campos Sánchez-Bordona – one of the ECJ’s 11 Advocate Generals who advise the top courts’ judges – argued in a court statement on Thursday that “general and indiscriminate retention of traffic and location data” is only permitted “in the event of a serious threat to national security”, for example, terrorist cases.

He added that murder cases do not apply.

The opinion, which is not an official ruling, is usually followed by ECJ judges and precedes any decision made by the court to assist it in a final judgment.

According to Gianclaudio Malgieri, an Associate Professor of Law and Technology at the EDHEC Business School in Lille, the court’s justices will probably agree with the Advocate General’s opinion.

“This opinion is likely to be confirmed by the court because it clearly builds on previous case law of the court, so it’s not built on previous Advocate General opinions, but it’s built on two recent cases from the court,” Malgieri told Euronews.

If the opinion is upheld it could shape how police across the continent gather evidence, potentially limiting their ability to harvest and utilise mobile phone traffic and location data in criminal investigations.

The Irish authorities argue that Dwyer’s conviction would not have been possible without being able to use the data found on mobile phones linked to the imprisoned killer.

His legal team, however, say that police were able to use his telephones as “personal tracking devices”, going against his civil liberties.

Campos Sánchez-Bordona also pointed out that the decision to access mobile phone data in Ireland is made at “the discretion of a police officer of a certain rank”, adding that this goes against previous EU case law, which states that access to data like this must be “subject to prior review by a court or an independent authority”.

Malgieri says the Advocate General did not believe that the decision to access Dwyer’s data was made by someone deemed to be independent and not linked to the investigation.

“An important implication for ongoing investigations and ongoing activities is that there should be an ex-ante authorisation by an independent authority, which in this case was not considered to be independent because it was just a public prosecutor,” Malgieri said.

“And so, the advocate general believed that the public prosecutor is not independent from the government,” he added.

A decision is expected around March next year.

Source

Leave your comment on this post

THE ROTTEN FISH: CAN OF WORMS OPENED OF APC & TINUBU'S GOVERNMENT OVER NIGERIA'S ECONOMIC DOWNTURN

WATCH THE CRITICAL ANALYSIS AND KNOW THE RESPONSIBLE PARTIES TO BLAME FOR NIGERIA'S ECONOMIC CHALLENGES, WHILE CITIZENS ENDURE SEVERE HARDSHIPS.

Watch this episode of ISSUES IN THE NEWS on 9News Nigeria featuring Peter Obi's Special Adviser, Dr Katch Ononuju, 9News Nigeria Publisher, Obinna Ejianya and Tinubu Support Group Leader, McHezekiah Eherechi

The economic crisis and hardship in Nigeria are parts of the discussion.


Watch, leave your comments, and share to create more awareness on this issue.


#9NewsNigeria #Nigeria #issuesInTheNews #politics #tinubu THE ROTTEN FISH: CAN OF WORMS OPENED ...
DON'T FORGET TO SUBSCRIBE AND LEAVE YOUR COMMENTS FOR SUBSEQUENT UPDATES
#9newsnigeria #economia #economy #nigeria #government @9newsng
www.9newsng.com

Leave your comment

Click on the link below or Scan the QR Code to join the 9News Nigeria WhatsApp Channel

9News Nigeria Investigative Reports WhatsApp Channel
9News Nigeria Investigative Reports WhatsApp Channel
About 9News Nigeria 13308 Articles
9News Nigeria is Nigeria's favourite news source. For Authentic, Unbiased News on Politics, Business, Sports, Technology, Entertainment and Lifestyles, Health, Nollywood, Crime and Investigations, Family and Relationships, Inspirations .. and much more. For Latest News from Africa and around the world, 9News Nigeria is your best source. WhatsApp +2348115805632 Email: info@9newsng.com Facebook: www.facebook.com/9NewsNG | Twitter/Instagram: @9newsng

Be the first to comment

Leave your comment